The Berlin competition film What Marielle Knows presents a compelling philosophical and psychological inquiry into the nature of truth and deception. The film follows Julia and Tobias, a seemingly perfect couple whose lives are upended when their daughter, Marielle, suddenly develops telepathic abilities, allowing her to perceive every thought and action of her parents. This newfound power disrupts the fragile balance of their relationship, revealing hidden secrets that threaten the cohesion of the family unit. The film raises profound ethical and existential questions about whether absolute truth is always desirable and whether deception can sometimes be a necessary component of social harmony.
I was once told a story about an elderly couple who had been married for over fifty years. One day, the husband found an old box hidden deep in the attic, containing letters his wife had written but never sent. Curious, he read through them, only to discover moments of doubt, hidden affections for another person, and worries she had kept secret to avoid hurting him. He was devastated but also understood that those secrets had allowed their marriage to endure. In What Marielle Knows, Marielle’s telepathic ability mirrors this dilemma—knowing everything about another and never telling lies might not always bring comfort; rather, it could unravel the relationships we hold dear.
This theme has a rich tradition in philosophy. Plato famously introduced the concept of the “noble lie” in The Republic, arguing that certain falsehoods, when strategically employed, can serve the greater good of societal order. Conversely, Immanuel Kant, in his deontological moral framework, vehemently opposed lying under any circumstance, asserting that truth-telling is a categorical imperative regardless of the consequences. Kant’s rigid stance, however, has been critiqued by later philosophers such as Friedrich Nietzsche, who viewed the very structure of human existence as one built on layers of deception and self-deception. Nietzsche argued that truth is often constructed rather than absolute and that illusions are sometimes necessary for human flourishing.
In fact, in every act, we engage in a selective forgetting of our true selves to conform to social norms. We shape our identities to fit the expectations of others, often presenting an idealized version of who we are. This performative nature of human existence necessitates occasional deception, as absolute honesty can sometimes lead to personal or social ruin. Throughout history, individuals have strategically withheld information or altered their narratives to avoid unnecessary conflict, embarrassment, or even harm. In personal relationships, complete transparency about past thoughts or fleeting desires could damage bonds that otherwise thrive on mutual understanding and selective ignorance. The tension between authenticity and the need for concealment is, therefore, not only a moral dilemma but an essential part of navigating human society.
What Marielle Knows effectively dramatizes these tensions. Marielle’s ability to perceive every hidden action and unspoken thought places her parents in a precarious position, where the very fabric of their relationship is at risk of unraveling. The film suggests that some secrets, while ethically questionable, are necessary for maintaining personal and social stability.
At the same time, What Marielle Knows is a surprisingly funny film, filled with moments of humor that had audiences in the theater laughing. The film skillfully balances philosophical depth with an honest and entertaining portrayal of human flaws. The humor does not dilute its message; rather, it enhances it, making the philosophical reflections more accessible. The actors’ performances contribute significantly to this, creating a believable and deeply human world.
The filmmakers have constructed a story that resonates because, as human beings, we all recognize that none of us are perfect—we are flawed, contradictory creatures, often concealing our real passions and emotions while presenting a curated version of ourselves to the world.
By weaving a gripping narrative with rich philosophical underpinnings, What Marielle Knows stands out as a thought-provoking and entertaining meditation on the nature of truth.
© 2020-2025. UniversalCinema Mag.